Monetary Policy vs Fiscal Policy

The aims of fiscal and monetary policy are similar. They are both used to:

  • keep inflation low (inflation target of 2%)
  • maintain positive economic growth (close to long run trend rate of 2.5%)
  • aim for full employment

The principle aim of fiscal and monetary policy is to reduce cyclical fluctuations in the economic cycle. Often it is inflation targeting which is stressed most for monetary policy.

  • Fiscal Policy involves changing government spending and taxation. It involves a shift in the governments budget position. e.g. Expansionary fiscal policy involves tax cuts, higher government spending and a bigger budget deficit.
  • Monetary policy involves influencing the demand and supply of money, primarily though the use of interest rates. It can also involves unorthodox policies such as open market operations and quantitative easing.

Reducing Inflation

To reduce inflationary pressures, the monetary authorities will try to reduce the growth of AD. If we use fiscal policy, it will invovle higher taxes, lower spending, the advantage is that we help to reduce the budget deficit.

In a country like the UK, with a large budget deficit, it makes sense to use fiscal policy for reducing any inflationary pressure. Because you can  reduce inflation and at the same time improve the budget deficit.

However, during normal periods of economic growth, deflationary fiscal policy may conflict with other objectives. For example raising taxes may affect incentives in the economy. Lower spending may adversely affect public services. It can be difficult to cut public spending for reasons of fiscal demand side management. This is why often we use monetary policy.

However, if we pursue deflationary fiscal policy and keep interest rates very low, savers may find they face negative real interest rates.

Raising interest rates is usually quite effective in reducing inflationary pressures (though there may be time lags, especially if confidence is very high).

  • Raising interest rates   also has an effect on the exchange rate. Due to hot money flows, the Pound is likely to rise. Therefore, deflationary monetary policy will have a greater effect on exporters.
  • Also raising interest rates has a bigger proportionate effect on homeowners with variable mortgage payments. The high level of mortgage payments, means the UK is sensitive to interest rate changes. However, higher interest rates can be beneficial for savers who will gain a higher income.
  • Therefore monetary policy doesn’t have an even impact throughout the economy; borrowers and savers will be effected differently.

Monetary Policy In Recession

In a recession, we will cut interest rates to try and stimulate spending and investment. It should also weaken the exchange rate which will help exports.

However, in some situations monetary policy may be insufficient. In the recession of 2008-09 there was  a liquidity trap. Cuts in interest rates were insufficient to encourage spending and investment. For example:

  • Banks had insufficient credit so were unwilling to lend despite low interest rates
  • Confidence was very low.
  • House prices were falling reducing consumer wealth

With deflation, interest rates may be insufficient, because falling prices can make real interest rates quite high. Therefore zero interest rates may not get an economy out of recession.

Extra Policies in Recession

In addition to cuts in interest rates it may be necessary to pursue quantitative easing and expansionary fiscal policy.

Quantitative easing helps to increase the money supply and avoid deflationary pressures. Expansionary fiscal policy can directly create jobs and economic activity by injecting money into the economy. Keynes argued expansionary fiscal policy is necessary in a recession because private sector saving can rise rapidly due to the paradox of thrift. Therefore government borrowing is necessary to maintain a reasonable level of economic activity.

The drawback of expansionary fiscal policy, is that it increases the budget deficit. Some argue this can lead to higher interest rates as markets require higher interest rates to fund borrowing.

However, if fiscal policy occurs in a recession it will be offsetting a rise in private sector saving. In many instances, government borrowing can increase in recessions without increasing bond yields. But, it is a balancing act, if borrowing increases too much, markets may fear borrowing is out of control. (see: European fiscal crisis)

Which is Best Monetary or Fiscal Policy?

Monetary policy is most widely used for ‘fine tuning’ the economy. Making small changes. However, monetary policy has its limitations. In serious recessions, we invariably need a combination of the two policies.

Related

12 Responses to Monetary Policy vs Fiscal Policy

  1. Mark Biernat June 7, 2010 at 10:44 am #

    What about neither? The government that governs least governs best. Fiscal policy just creates crowds out private investment and monetary policy perpetuates disequalibrium. Let the markets work.

    • aldreyna March 1, 2013 at 8:54 am #

      letting the invisible hand determine is a very attractive option but what about when the market fails, of which history has taught us to involve our capitalisms with an tinge of public coordination. the truth in this case being that a fuse of both policies with a lot of policy checkers does the work.

  2. Michaal Adewale June 21, 2010 at 2:37 pm #

    i want you to tell me how macroeconomi describes the economy in terms of macroeconomic variables, the objectives of macroeconomic policy, principal instrument of monetary policy, what is fiscal & monetary policy and outline a fiscal policy for a developing country.
    Thanks.

  3. nikkilarsson December 27, 2010 at 7:53 am #

    I want to tell you that Monetary policy is the actions of a central bank, currency board or other regulatory committee that determine the size and rate of growth of the money supply, which in turn affects interest rates. But Fiscal policy is related with spending money and taxation.

  4. RENU RANA January 5, 2011 at 9:22 am #

    it is a rbi’s action to control or increase money supply in the economy which increase or decrease purchasing power in economy to meet problems regarding inflation/deflation

  5. Negassi Paulos March 30, 2011 at 2:19 pm #

    I don’t think that the monetary actions are exclusively the role of financial institutions though they are the guiders. because every individual has some role in taking actions and responding as a reaction.

  6. Fox June 1, 2011 at 3:27 am #

    Fiscal and monetary policy are used as am means to extract as much money and resources from the population without them knowing they are being fleeced. Get a clue

    • TheGuyBelowMe November 4, 2011 at 3:26 am #

      @Fox
      I don’t think you quite understand how economics work, and I suggest that you figure that out before you start commenting in a condescending tone. If neither of the policies were enacted I can guarantee you that you’d lose a hell of a lot more money than you would with either of the two policies.

  7. Mrs.J June 13, 2013 at 11:25 pm #

    I have this for an assignment and what I’m finding is that when it comes down to which one would be better suited for a recession. Honestly neither one is a smart option. One has a major draw back of creating more issue that is solving and the other may not be sufficient enough. But if you’d have to choose one fiscal policy makes more sense.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Outline: Eid « ISC Sussex Foundation 2010-11 - April 18, 2011

    [...] http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/economics/monetary-policy-vs-fiscal-policy/ . Last accessed 18th Apr 2011. • Unknown. (Unknown). Economic Polices To Control [...]

  2. research essay: Eid « ISC Sussex Foundation 2010-11 - May 7, 2011

    [...] (2010). Monetary Policy vs Fiscal Policy. Available:  http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/economics/monetary-policy-vs-fiscal-policy/ . Last accessed 18th Apr [...]

  3. Knifonomics (part 19): listen to your elders « The Knife and me - April 24, 2012

    [...] fiscal (ie. government controlled, rather than Bank of England) macroeconomic policy. See here and here for handy definitions. Like this:LikeBe the first to like this post. [...]