I’m off to New York on Wednesday, I’m tempted to stay until May 8th, so I can miss the UK General election campaigning, which so far has been quite depressing for the poor quality of economic debate.
This is just an outline of some issues for consideration. I may expand upon these in the coming weeks.
Whose fault was the 2008/09 economic crash? –
Essentially a global financial crisis, exacerbated by weak financial regulation. But, who was advocating much stricter regulation of the banks pre 2007?
Would the great recession have been worse?
- if UK had been in EURO.
- If UK had not pursued expansionary fiscal policy in 2009
- If Bank of England had not pursued expansionary monetary policy
Was the great depression caused by reckless government borrowing under Labour?
In 2007/08, UK public sector debt was close to the lowest level achieved since before the First World War in 1914.
See also: Government debt under Labour
Note debt levels in 1945, when Labour introduced NHS, welfare state and nationalised key industries!
Is reducing the budget deficit an important economic objective – when the economy is recovering from recession?
Reducing debt may be an important political objective. But, ironically, many economists feel that reducing deficits (through austerity) can be counter-productive.
Why is austerity so politically popular, when so many economists state it is damaging?
What is the economic impact on immigration on the UK economy?
Many benefits for tax revenue, labour supply, economic growth and reducing debt to GDP. Though it does add to the added pressure on housing market, congestion and transport.
Economic record of the coalition
1. Economic growth
Economic recovery – better than Europe.
Recovery came, but did period of austerity in 2011 unnecessarily delay the recovery? Should the recovery have been much stronger? Have we permanently lost output? Austerity pros and cons
2. Inflation – now falling below target. Why 0% inflation rate is a real problem
3. Unemployment – unemployment has fallen much faster than expected, suggesting UK labour markets very flexible. The downside is that many jobs are flexible, part-time, zero hour contracts.
4. Real incomes – Prolonged period of falling real incomes, hitting those in low-paid work the most.
5. Housing market – increased house prices have led to increased living costs, creating greater inequality between those who own a house (usually older generation) and those renting or trying to buy. Fundamental problem is shortage of housing. Can the UK have the political will to build enough houses? Probably not.
Why do politicians try to solve housing shortage / housing crisis by offering subsidised mortgages and trying to return us to 1980s? (Telegraph link)
Did the UK actually have austerity?
Overall, a very mild form of austerity. See data on extent of austerity
There was a cut in government spending in 2010/11 – but mostly total real government spending has increased. Still some departments, such as welfare have seen cuts, as more money has been spent on pensions and health care.
Popularity vs Economics
Are taxes always a bad thing? It depends
Economists state some taxes can increase economic efficiency, equity and have benefits
Land tax – advocated by Economist
Higher petrol tax – advocated by Economic help
Obesity tax – why spend more money on NHS, when it would be better to encourage healthier lifestyles, and not just treat symptoms of poor lifestyle