Readers Question: What caused the massive decrease in the debt to GDP ratio for the UK following World War II?

It is a good question to ask. Despite setting up welfare state, NHS and house building programme UK debt as a share of GDP fell. (as it did in many other countries. But, UK debt was particularly high in the late 1940s)
Summary
UK national debt peaked in the late 1940s at over 230% of GDP. From the early 1950s to early 1990s, we see a consistent decrease in the debt to GDP ratio. At the start of the global credit crunch in 2007, public sector debt was 38% of GDP.
Higher government spending in post-war period
Firstly, debt to GDP was definitely not reduced through cutting government expenditure.

Note – Debt to GDP fell, despite higher real government spending on the newly formed welfare state and national health service. In fact, government spending as a % of GDP rose from around 35% of GDP in the early 1950s to the high 40%s in the 1970s.

Source: OBR
Why did UK debt to GDP fall?

If GDP is rising, then even if debt goes up, the debt to GDP ratio can fall.
- Economic growth was averaging 2.5% +. Total real debt increased in this period, but GDP increased at a faster rate. Therefore, the debt to GDP ratio fell.
- Positive inflation.
- Patience. After the early 1950s, debt to GDP fell over the next four decades. It took a long time to reduce debt to GDP.
- Relatively low budget deficits (though the UK very rarely had a budget surplus)
- Decline in defense budget

In 1960s, the UK was still spending 7% of GDP on defence. The end of the Empire, end of conscription and cutbacks to the armed forces saw defence spending fall to 2% of GDP by 2017. This enables the rise in health care spending as a share of GDP.
Postwar economic boom

This graph shows UK real GDP. In 1955 it was less than £7,000 per capita. By 2010, it was £28,000 per capita. Living standards improved and there was a substantial increase in real GDP
This graph also explains the sharp rise in debt as a % of GDP from 2007-2020 – real GDP per-capita stagnated and stopped growing.
UK post-war inflation

Inflation played a role in helping to erode the real value of debt. In the post-war period inflation was averaging 3-5% – with periods of near double-digit inflation.

In the post war period, the government had more control over bond yieldsand they were kept artificially low.
In the post-war period, rather than letting markets push up yields, the authorities actively capped them.
- Long-term gilt yields were kept low by policy, not market forces
- In 1945-51, long-term gilt yields were kept around 2½–3% to finance war debt. A degree of control persisted even after the end of ‘cheap’ money
- Banks, insurers, and pension funds were encouraged or required to hold gilts
- The Bank stood ready to buy or sell gilts to maintain target prices
- The Treasury and Bank operated in close coordination (far less independence)
Unexpected inflation of the 1970s
There were also periods in the 1970s when some of the debt was reduced through the effects of inflation. Inflation was higher than bondholders expected, so there were periods of negative real interest rates. But, it wasn’t just a matter of inflating away the debt. (see blog on inflating away the debt?)
UK post-war budget deficit

The UK did not reduce the debt by running budget surpluses.
Unemployment

A key element of the post-war consensus was virtually full employment. This reduces the amount of welfare payments and also means economy is running well.
What caused economic growth in the post-war period?
- Global economic boom
The UK economy benefited from the period of rapid global economic growth, especially in Western Europe. In fact, in this period, UK growth lagged behind many of our Western European neighbours. But, overall the UK enjoyed a period of rapid growth in trade and economic growth. The global economic boom was helped by
- Recovery of Japan and Germany
- Low global inflation
- Increased free trade, with reduction of tariff barriers
- Relative political and economic stability
- Technological improvements, such as computers, better petrol engines. Some of these technological improvements were quite low-tech like containerisation,
2. Immigration
UK growth was so rapid that the economy experienced labour shortages. This led to the mass immigration of the 1950s and 60s to help deal with the labour market shortages. Note, the UK was experiencing large scale emigration, so overall net migration was quite low. Due to migration and baby-boomer generation the working population and increase real GDP. GDP per capita rose at a slower pace than actual real GDP.
3. Improved education
In the post-war period, there was a growth in university education, and secondary education became more comprehensive.
4. Effective demand management
One of the cornerstones of William Beveridge’s Welfare proposals was the assumption that a comprehensive welfare state required considerable efforts to achieve near full employment. The UK experienced boom and bust cycles, but the downturns were relatively minor, and there were no real recessions of any significance until 1973.
In the post-war period, the government controlled monetary policy and fiscal policy and had a willingness to cut interest rates during economic slowdowns. The benign global economic conditions helped give a low trade-off between inflation and unemployment.
UK growth could have been higher
Many commentators state that although the UK did enjoy a post-war economic boom, it was actually a missed opportunity and our relative competitiveness declined. The UK had many failings such as
- Uncompetitive industry
Poor industrial relations
- Lack of vocational training
- A degree of complacency – not felt in countries, such as Japan and Germany.
High tax rates
- Another feature of the 1940s, 50s and 60s were very high marginal tax rates. The Second World War created a political climate which tolerated extremely high-income tax rates. The highest rate of income tax peaked in the Second World War at 99.25%. It was slightly reduced after the war and was around 90% through the 1950s and 60s.
- In 1971 the top-rate of income tax on earned income was cut to 75%. Though a surcharge of 15% on investment income kept the top rate on that income at 90%. The top rate of income tax was cut to 40% in the late 1980s.
- With income tax rates of 70% plus. Rising incomes will lead to significant increase in tax revenues for the government.
- There was more effort to tax capital. In 1965, James Callaghan, the then chancellor introduced capital gains tax of 30pc to stop people avoiding income tax by switching their income into capital.
- Tax revenue was regularly over 40% of GDP.
Cost of servicing UK debt in post-war period
Despite the high levels of UK debt, the cost of servicing UK debt remained relatively low (less than 4% of GDP). This is a reflection of relatively low-interest rates. It is also interesting to note the current cost of servicing national debt is lower than in the 50s, 60s, and 70s.

Conclusion
The fall in UK national debt as a % of GDP reflects one of the important issues regarding debt reduction – take care of economic growth and unemployment and this will play a considerable role in reducing debt to GDP ratios.
The UK experience of the 1950s and 60s is in complete contrast to the current European experiment of sacrificing growth to meet deficit reduction targets – the result being often rising debt to GDP ratios in Europe.
However, it is worth bearing in mind that the post war period is often referred to as the ‘golden period of economic expansion’. The UK was helped by several factors, which enabled it to borrow such a large amount. These factors included:
- High personal savings ratio
- Government control over interest rates
- Patriotic effect of buying ‘war bonds’
- A generous loan from the US which we took a long time to pay back.
- Rapid global growth which made debt reduction much easier.
In the current climate, many of these factors are not there.
- Burnt by the credit crunch, investors are possibly more sceptical about government debt, especially since resurgence of inflation in 2021
- The outlook for global growth looks less promising – especially with our main trading partners.
- It is all very well saying all we need to do is to increase real incomes and boost economic growth, but in practise it might not be as easy as that.
- Government could keep bond yields low because there were closed capital accounts (no free global flows)
- Highly regulated banking system
- Strong home bias in savings
- Political acceptance of state direction of finance
- Could the UK happily borrow 230% of GDP like in the late 1940s? – I don’t think so. But the 1950s and 1960s do remind us growth is better than austerity for reducing debt.. The striking thing is the steady reduction in debt to GDP, whilst at the same time seeing real government spending levels rise.
Debt as % of GDP more important than budget deficit
One final point is that debt as % of GDP is a more important statistic than a budget deficit. Total debt reflects the long-term situation better than annual deficits which are influenced by cyclical factors.
In the past eight years, debt has increased to 80% of GDP but is beginning to stabilise.
The main reason UK debt to GDP fell in the post-war period was the sustained period of economic growth and near full employment until the late 1970s. This growth saw rising real incomes which in turn led to higher tax revenues and falling debt to GDP ratios.
There was also a positive inflation rate, which helped erode the real value of debt.
Related
Tejvan Pettinger studied PPE at LMH, Oxford University.
Holy cow, im 14 and this stuff sounds pretty complex (im just starting to dive into economy and such..